不要放弃!FAS -> Laid off -> Product Manager Offer

大家好,自从我大四以来,我一直在这个论坛上工作了3 - 4年,当时我发现WSO。I have absorbed a lot from this forum, about the financial services industry, and financial thinking in general.

Too long to read: Don't give up on your job search !

大学本科:

非目标本科生,前40名。该机构没有财务专业的专业,但仍未确定。我研究了数学和经济学。双专业造成了一些伤害我的GPA。我在高三的寒假期间发现了金融业。到那时,我知道我很少知道,因为我知道这么少,所以我去参加银行的全职招聘可能为时已晚。
After graduation, I managed to secure an internship at a very small buysideM&Aadvisory shop. The work was super tedious. I was only doing very basic qualitative research: googling and compiling very vague data into2ManBetX登陆 床单。近三个月后,我辞职了,因为我并没有真正学习任何东西。另一个重要因素是创始人/老板。他喜欢告诉实习生有关他正在做的慈善事业和刚租用的新跑车。我真的不是想留在哪里。

Foot in the door:

我以某种方式设法确保了长期的循环股票研究实习a lower middle-market bank. It was in the west coast, and for those of youwho doER在西海岸,您知道生活方式。在我的软技能,职业道德,应对压力的能力以及生产高质量工作产品的能力方面,我在那里长大了。起初这是一场挣扎,但我设法工作了半年。
我决定不留下。令人惊讶的是,生活方式不是破坏交易的人,而是医学博士。对于我来说,他对我进行了太多的管理,无法在未来两年内过渡到全职角色并继续为他工作。我离开后几个月,另一个长期实习生 - 我们基本上是分析师,他们像实习生一样得到报酬,考虑到我们所做的工作量和工作类型 - - 然后几个月后离开了团队,也是一名全日制研究助理。几个月后,另一位副总裁研究助理最终成为一名高级分析师,这意味着我的Orignal MD现在没有人可以使用,除了1-2个薪水不佳的实习生。

MSFand Networking:

我回家大约两个月,然后去了MSFprogram, hoping to jump from there. I was glad that the business school I went to indeed has a lot of resources and a ton of alumni working in finance. I networked heavily. I'm from China (been here 7 years) and before I went to theMSFprogram, I would wake up around 4:30 or 5am every morning at home to get on networking calls. Didn't remember exactly how many calls I made. I was focusing on middle market banks and some boutiques, as I knewBBsandEBswould be highly competitive. Built some great connections over the phone, and got some cold welcomes too.

I had 2 contacts pushing my resume for me before school started. I thought I did well in both, especially for one毫米, where I networked with 6-7 people in the office. The associate who was interviewing me even said this: hey, you are here because you've done your homework. For this round, let's just chat. After this one, go prepare for technicals for the next 1-2 rounds. Eventually, they did not let me pass that round.

I continued to interview.IB,PE, Corp Dev, FP&A, anything related that I could fetch. One big issue was the sponsorship. Since I need a work sponsorship, almost all banks I networked with, stopped sponsoring getting into the 2018-2019 recruiting cycle, including 2 banks where I knew sponsored my friends who pushed resume for me.
During November, 2018, I passed 3 rounds of interviews for a global tech firm's corp deve team, only waiting for the 4th round's result to come out. The first 3 rounds were great: all interviewers let me pass on the spot. The director, who interviewed me for the 3rd round, told me this before we ended the conversation: I've already put you in the final round. I like you a lot and I want to hire you. Prepare well for the last round.
The last one was with a C-level guy from Japan/Korea, and we were having a difficult time communicating since his English was not very good. He also asked me one totally unexpected, but very thought-provoking question: what do you want to do after 20 years? Tbh, I've never thought beyond 10 years before, only vaguely about 20 years.
I waited for 5 weeks and I had calls with the HR every week. Finally, she told me they decided not to hire candidates.

Before the 1-year program ended, I interviewed for about 50 companies in total, not counting the rounds of interviews. I know this number might not be a lot for some of you here, but I really tried everything I could do to get interviews and pass them. I stopped crazily throwing out resumes around April, seeing very few available positions for me to target.

FAS job offer:

In June, one day I got an email from a company about a FAS consultant position. I did not even remember when I sent my resume, but I said yes.
1st round was a 30 minute interview with a director, who later sat next to me in the office. Half technicals, half unexpected but reasonable questions such as : you took a course in group theory, tell me about it. Okay.
2nd round was a bit surprising: they asked me to come to纽约for an on-site assessment, which consists of two parts: the 1st part is a one-hour written test: math, finance, logic, and reading. The 2nd part was a case study, more like a consulting-type than a finance case study.

I was super close to the answer for the case study before time ran out. I didn't think I did too well on that test.

To my surprise, the next day, the director called. I passed, and they wanted me to go to the office for a final round, which consists of two parts: a 1.5-hour financial case study, basically strategy分析DCF建模和30-40分钟的合作伙伴面试。我在案例研究中做错了什么,这是一个小错误,导演说很好。我在伴侣面试中表现不错。这是伙伴和另一位导演。

我唯一的抱怨是,即使我开始在那里工作,他们也没有偿还我的飞行票或酒店费用。费用问题稍后出现了很多次。

I took the offer 7 days later, the same day they extended it.
Thinking about it, I should have given myself more time to decide: later, I had interviews at GIC/Temasec, and got an offer at a Charlotte-basedIBboutique, who gave me a meaningfully higer salary. I decided for the FAS role since the clients (Carlyle,黑色的石头) and deals they work on are global and high-profile. Plus, I do not know anyone in Charlotte, and I want to be in纽约
Indeed, I got great exposure and I learned a lot.

Laid-off:

学到了很多东西,但没有我想要的那么多。三月份,我的工作超过6个月,我被遗弃了。全球负责人引用了收入和病毒的下降。我没有责怪或大喊,谈判了遣散费,照顾了文书工作,第二天开始编辑我的简历。我的医学博士,一位分析师和我的经理在同一天被解雇。合作伙伴引用了收入大幅下降。
I had many calls with headhunters as well as direct interviews over the following 2.5-3 months. Over 85-90% of them did not sponsor, once they heard my situation. Some calls only lasted for 10-15 seconds because of this, including a couple valuation positions atEBs令我惊讶的是,不赞助人,也许他们只是赞助全职的夏季分析师。
Again, I casted a very wide net: research,IB,PE(my experience has been in renewable and infrastructure), corp deve, project finance,asset management, fintech (I touted my self-learned programming skills and put some sample projects on GitHub), quant finance (I'm a math major after all, although I did not pass the 2nd rounds because it's been too long). Got very close with a couple firms, but eventually did not pass. I was focusing on building sample models to demonstrate my modeling ability --- I don't build models very fast, but I wanted to show I could do it.
在1小时的构建中,预测5年和DCFmodeling exercise, I panicked, and fumbled.

Product Manager Offer:

I have been taking online courses in product management, programming, and brushingup on finance interview questions, such as theWSO指导。我将PM视为我想进入的路线,因为经过3-4个月的努力,我意识到自己想建造产品并创办公司。这是非常冒险的,因为我真的没有太多的储蓄,而且由于我需要学习iOS开发,这会很耗时。但是,我发现,如果我能在产品管理领域找到工作,我将拥有一项宝贵的技能,成为一名企业家。

4 rounds of interview: first 2 rounds with PMs. One guy is a SternMBA。他的背景与我的背景相似。第三轮是耶鲁MBA, who has built his whole career in IT/Tech companies. He tries to warn me about the salary negotiation: "young man, you are lucky to be alive and maybe have a job in 2020 !"

第四/决赛:人力资源。薪水还可以,CNY/RMB中的总COMP 250K+。有了我1 - 2年的经验,我不会称这种薪水不好:它与Bat的报价相当,奖金结构较低。

I'm still looking for other good opportunities, but the deadline of taking the offer is approaching, and I do not want to take a huge risk in 2020.

For those of you who got laid off as well, or those of non-targets who are struggling to break into finance orIB, don't give up ! Maybe you walk slowly, but as long as you walk, you will get somewhere. It may not be the place you want the most, but you won't fail yourself either.

I know this post is super long, and I hope it is helpful to some of you here. Thank you all.

评论 (7)

最有帮助的
2y
Incoming cfa level 1 charterholder, what's your opinion? Comment below:

I would take the money. You can always find a better job opportunity一旦经济gets a little better.

我可能会太多看您的帖子,但是我感觉您真的很着迷于金钱,并感觉到您一直在面试,并且可能在上一份工作中以错误的方式摩擦了某些人。从我的理解来看,FAS目前做得很好,一家将与您提到的客户合作的公司可能有稳定的收入,这使我相信您以前的声明,您以您的饥饿/饥饿/面试所有时间的态度(这可能不是真的,但这是我得到的印象。

My advice to you: Work on your attitude. Don't give off the impression that you're job hunting and looking to leave for the first firm that will offer you a few more $.

Again, I might be reading too much into what you wrote, but it's the impression I'm getting.

Array
  • 3
  • 分析师1Other
2y

Hi sir, thanks a lot for the comment. I think you are right. I actually haven't negotiated salaries too much, and I have given not a more lucrative offer from Charlotte when I came to纽约, but I have to admit that my attitude is money hungry, maybe not on the surface, but subconsciously. On the reason for the layoff, the revenue declined more than 50% YoY. The fees were not paid or cleared on time. I'm one of the few who got laid off. Updated the post.

2y
Richard.3, what's your opinion? Comment below:

This is a complete humble brag. I would take a $200K offer at a tech firm to work 40 hours a week at age 22 any day!

Will update my computer soon and leave Incognito so I will disappear forever. How did I achieve Neanderthal by trolling? Some people are after me so need to close account for safety.
  • 分析师1Other
2y

正确的。我没有工作GSorMS or Evercore,真的没有太多声望来吹牛。确保工作非常困难,产品经理的要约也有一些运气。

Learn More

300+ video lessons across 6 modeling courses taught by elite practitioners at the top investment banks and private equity funds -- Excel Modeling -- Financial Statement Modeling -- M&A Modeling -- LBO Modeling -- DCF and Valuation Modeling -- ALL INCLUDED + 2 Huge Bonuses.

Learn more
2y
kazeemwahid, what's your opinion? Comment below:

250k rmb?所以要约在中国?

  • 分析师1Other
2y

Molestiae voluptatum labore ullam atque non hic. Omnis aut et cum numquam culpa aliquid sit. Est eum autem laborum. Corporis est omnis provident est perferendis autem.

Non molestiae ipsa itaque beatae id. Similique qui nesciunt odio dolores enim eaque. Asperiores esse voluptas enim perferendis molestias repudiandae eum. Ut sit aut nulla voluptates aliquam. Quia voluptatem ea dicta tempore qui.

Start Discussion

职业发展机会

2023年2月万博app网页版

  • Lazard Freres(+ +) 99.5%
  • Jefferies&Company(▽01) 99.1%
  • Lincoln International(▽01) 98.6%
  • Financial Technology Partners(▽01) 98.1%
  • William Blair(▲08) 97.7%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

2023年2月万博app网页版

  • Canaccord Genuity(▲04) 99.5%
  • William Blair(▲04) 99.0%
  • Lincoln International(▲09) 98.6%
  • Jefferies&Company(▲06) 98.1%
  • Financial Technology Partners(▲09) 97.6%

Professional Growth Opportunities

2023年2月万博app网页版

  • Lazard Freres(▲15) 99.5%
  • Financial Technology Partners(▲09) 99.1%
  • Lincoln International(= =) 98.6%
  • Jefferies&Company(▽03) 98.1%
  • William Blair(▲01) 97.7%

Total Avg Compensation

2023年2月万博app网页版

  • Director/MD (6) $592
  • 副总裁(24) $418
  • Associates (137) $ 262
  • 第三年+年分析师(9) $194
  • 2nd Year Analyst (80) $172
  • 1st Year Analyst (258) $171
  • Intern/Summer Associate (42) $166
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (185) $91

LeaderboardSee all

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
BankonBanking的图片
BankonBanking
99.0
3
pudding's picture
pudding
99.0
4
卡农的照片
卡农
99.0
5
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
6
Compbanker的图片
compbanker
98.9
7
secyh62's picture
secyh62
98.9
8
Jamoldo's picture
Jamoldo
98.9
9
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
10
GameTheory的图片
GameTheory
98.9